College interviews are rarely decisive — a great interview won’t overcome a weak application, and a mediocre interview rarely sinks a strong one. But at the margins, especially for selective schools where many applicants are academically equivalent, a memorable interview can tip the balance. More importantly, it’s often your only chance to present yourself as a person rather than a file.
Alumni vs. admissions officer interviews#
Most selective school interviews are conducted by alumni volunteers, not admissions officers. Alumni interviews are typically conversational and low-pressure; the interviewer is often just looking for evidence that you’re a real, thoughtful person. Know which type you’re doing and calibrate your preparation accordingly.
What interviewers are actually looking for#
Not rehearsed answers. Not a perfect résumé recitation. Interviewers are trying to answer two questions:
- Is this a person I’d enjoy talking to for an hour? (intellectual curiosity, genuine engagement)
- Would this person contribute something interesting to our campus community?
The students who give the best interviews are the ones who treat it as a genuine conversation, not a performance. They ask real questions. They change direction when something interesting comes up. They’re clearly themselves.
Sources and method
Use the official references below to check requirements and deadlines for your own schools and application cycle.
Suggested attribution: Dewey Smart. “The College Interview Guide” (published 2026-08-18). https://www.deweysmart.com/resources/college-interview-guide.
When quoting a figure, include its data year and population, and retain its source link. Reuse terms.
